Blog Layout

Why do Abuse Victims Stay?

Beverley Stewart • June 11, 2023

Why do Abuse Victims Stay?

Why Do Abuse Victims Stay?

 

For those who haven’t had the misfortune to be involved in an abusive relationship, the reason a victim stays can sometimes be hard to imagine. I’ve often heard people say, “If it was so bad, why didn’t they just leave?” To outsiders it’s a valid question. To those experiencing abuse, it’s a stupid question. Here we identify why some abuse victims stay and why leaving just doesn’t seem an option.


 

A Growing Issue

Statistics show that 23% of Australian women have experienced physical violence by a former or current intimate partner (ABS, 2017). This means many of us may have first hand experience, or know someone who has. Sometimes the decision to leave an abusive partner is a no brainer. But often it’s a complicated decision that puts even more pressure on the victim and intensifies their trauma.


Studies have shown that the most dangerous time for a victim of domestic abuse is when they attempt to leave the relationship (or shortly after they have left). Perpetrators will go to extreme measures to ensure their victim doesn’t leave them. Once an abuser feels they’re no longer able to maintain control over their victim, their abuse often intensifies. Hearing about shocking incidents of murder taking place after a partner leaves, or threatens to leave the relationship, is far too common. 


There are SO MANY reasons why a victim stays in this toxic relationship. Below are some examples that demonstrate how complex these situations can be and how the abuser keeps their victim trapped.


Fear

Most reasons for staying are based on fear. The victim is put in the position of having to decide whether their fears about staying are greater or lesser, than the potential repercussions of leaving. They may judge that remaining in the relationship is safer because, if they leave, they may be unable to protect themselves and those they love from the escalating abuse. A 2018 study by ANROWS (Australia’s National Research Organisation for Women’s Safety) reported that, on average, each week one woman in Australia is murdered by her current or former partner. 


Abusers will often threaten the following to incite fear in their victims:


  • increased violence or killing their partner
  • harming or killing the children
  • taking custody of children
  • harming or killing pets, extended family, friends
  • denying access to financial assets or support


Abuse victims are very knowledgeable about the capabilities of their abuser and know these threats are genuine. 


Other credible fears are:


  • friends and family will not be supportive of them leaving
  • inability to cope as a single parent
  • inability to financially support themselves and children
  • belief that the children would be better off with two parents
  • insufficient knowledge about how to escape (no access to safety and support services)
  • nowhere to go (no friends/family they can go to, no money for accommodation, lack of refuge/shelter beds)
  • being homeless
  • not being believed (Often the abuse has been kept secret from others and victims worry that no one will believe that abuse has been taking place.) 




Culture & Society

)Cultural obstacles also exist to complicate things when it comes to leaving an abusive relationship.  Some of these are:


1) Law Enforcement – Police may disregard accusations of abuse and consider it a “domestic dispute”.  Consequently, the victim may feel they won’t be taken seriously, and the abuse will be dismissed. (Ironically, if it were two strangers involved, it would always be considered a crime.)

  

2) Court System – Potentially the victim can lose custody of the children, or lose joint financial assets. There is sometimes also a reluctance to prosecute domestic abuses cases, and a lesser charge may be brought on the perpetrator.  A fine or probation are often the outcome, further risking the safety of the victim.  Unfortunately, in reality, restraining orders don’t prevent the abuser from tracking down their ex-partner and repeating the abuse.


3) Religious Doctrine – Some religious or spiritual groups maintain that individuals have an obligation to maintain the family unit at all costs (despite abuse).  The inference is that you’re a failure as a person if you fail to keep your marriage together.


4) Cost of Living Pressures – Inability to support self/children, or a decrease in standard of living may occur. In Australia in 2020-2021, the greatest cause of homelessness was family and domestic violence with nearly 120,000 people seeking support (ABS 2023).


5) Intergenerational Role Modelling – Previous generations were far more accepting of “knockin’ the missus round”. It was part of life in some relationships, and victims didn’t feel they could speak out.  The law did not recognize the criminality of abuse.  In some families, these “traditions” were handed down from generation to generation. Children saw abuse between their parents, and now they in turn role model that behaviour in their own relationships. In this case the abuse victim will believe abuse is just part of life.


6) Isolation – An abuser will often ensure their partner becomes disconnected from friends and family.  Additionally, the victim can feel ashamed of the abuse and do their best to hide any signs of it from others.  This usually leads to self-isolation.  With limited external contacts, victims can feel they have no where to go if they leave.


7) Pressure to Conform – Cultural norms, social media and reality shows all tell us we should be in a long term, loving relationship – “coupled up”.  If you’re not able to keep your man, there’s something wrong with you!  Feelings of self-worth can be affected by having to admit that your relationship is over.


  

Love

Strangely, the victim may, despite the abuse, manipulation, intimidation, and the toxicity of the relationship, still feel love for their partner.  They may remember the happy times.  They may believe their abuser when they say, “Sorry. It will never happen again”.  The victim may hold hope that their partner will change.  An outsider will no doubt see the senselessness of such a hope, but when a victim is on the inside, logic and reasoning are not part of their thinking.


The victim may rationalize that factors such as alcohol, work problems, stress, financial worries, unemployment etc. are the cause of their abuser’s behaviour.  Victims excuse the abuse as a necessary way for their partner to blow off steam.  In these circumstances victims justify the harm done, and wait patiently for things to change.  This view is confirmed when the abuse changes to periods of love and kindness, before things escalate again as the cycle continues.



In The End ....

There are many reasons abuse victims stay. Each situation is different and complex. If you are in an abusive relationship, know that there is support out there. A professional can help you assess your personal situation and work with you to decide the best options for you to move forward. Remember - none of this is your fault. You don’t deserve this. You need to take care of yourself. You’re not alone.


For those that are not in abusive relationship – keep in mind that one in four of us have been a victim of intimate partner abuse. Tomorrow, where ever you are – at work, sport, the pub, shopping …. look around and know that someone standing next to you is probably going home to a nightmare. 


Emergency crisis numbers are here


Talking to a counsellor about your personal situation can be a positive step in ending the abuse. See Relationship Services page for further information or contact here.



By Beverley Stewart July 7, 2024
Coercive control is a concerning and growing issue in Australia - and it matters to all of us. But what is it really? Here we provide a definition, examine behaviours, and identify the signs. We also look at the effects coercive control can have, and what we can do about it.
By Beverley Stewart March 3, 2024
Ever wondered if you get less fun in your life than everyone else? You're not alone. Find the reasons behind this misconception.. It might just help you have more fun!
By Beverley Stewart February 25, 2024
Finding the silver lining in negative situations is a skill we can all develop. It's not easy at first, but it's a good habit to have. You can learn to see the positives around you and enjoy a more rewarding life - it just takes a little effort.
By Beverley Stewart February 18, 2024
From time to time we all want to change who we are. Yes we can change. Even our personality can be transformed. But if we want to change we need a plan, passion, optimism , and a lot of hard work.
By Beverley Stewart February 11, 2024
Life is short we're told. Coming to that realisation can affect us all in different ways. It can create anxiety, a sense of urgency, regret, and make us question how we should spend our remaining time. If life is short - how do we live our best life?
By Beverley Stewart February 4, 2024
Emotions play a big role in how we respond to situations when we feel life isn't fair. Recognising and accepting that these emotions are valid is part of the process that helps us move through life's challenges and bounce back with more positivity.
By Beverley Stewart January 28, 2024
Yes - bad stuff happens to good people. It's no wonder many of us think life isn't fair. Despite believing there is some natural law that should make things fair, society and psychology contribute more than anything to this feeling of unfairness.
By Beverley Stewart January 21, 2024
Loneliness has become a worldwide issue. Learning more about loneliness and it's association with suicidal thoughts can help you better navigate this challenge, or show you how to help someone you know who is struggling.
By Beverley Stewart January 14, 2024
Understanding the connection between loneliness and depression can help us better manage our situation. The relationship is often unclear so here we learn about similarities, differences and the cycle that can develop.
By Beverley Stewart January 7, 2024
Looking for change in the New Year? Here are 3 fun and creative tools to help ensure this year is one of personal growth and new beginnings. Maybe even a New Me!
More Posts
Share by: